All Romance Options in Arcadie II: Cold Lands – A Complete Guide

In Arcadie II: Cold Lands, there are three major, fully-developed romance options you can continue from the first game: your steadfast advisor Cyril, your loyal commander Will, and your primary antagonist, the formidable Valerius. This guide covers all romance options in Arcadie II, detailing the critical choices, quests, and approval thresholds needed to win the heart of your chosen partner—or betray everything for a forbidden connection.

While you can flirt with multiple characters initially, you will eventually be forced to choose one. Polyamory between the main romanceable characters is not an option; attempting it will lead to a confrontation where you must commit or lose them both.

01

The Core Companions: Your Allied Romancestag

Your two primary allies from the start of the game, Cyril and Will, represent the most traditional romance paths. Both can be male or female depending on your choices in the first game, and both are available to a player of any gender. Successfully romancing them requires consistently high Approval (generally above 60%) and siding with them in key moments of political and personal crisis.

Cyril: The Diplomat's Dancetag

Cyril, heir to House Lavignac and your most trusted advisor, is a romance of equals centered on mutual respect, wit, and political maneuvering. Their approval is won through thoughtful diplomacy, showing mercy, and trusting their counsel over brute force. They value a ruler who is measured and clever.

Key Quests & Decisions:

• "The Grain Gambit" (Chapter 2): When deciding how to handle the southern food shortages, you must choose Cyril's proposed solution of a diplomatic trade agreement over Will's suggestion of seizing supplies. This provides a major Approval boost.
• "A Poisoned Chalice" (Chapter 4): During the assassination attempt, trusting Cyril's instincts and following their lead to uncover the conspirators is crucial. Afterwards, choosing the dialogue option "I couldn't have done it without you" deepens the bond.
• Lock-In Point: The romance with Cyril is locked in during their personal quest, "Legacy of Lavignac" in Chapter 6. After helping them navigate a dispute with their family, you will have a private moment. Choosing to affirm your commitment here makes the relationship official. Backing away will permanently close the romance path.

Cyril disapproves of needless cruelty and tyrannical actions. Executing prisoners without trial, making aggressive threats in negotiations, or consistently ignoring their advice will quickly lower their Approval and can lead to them breaking off the relationship, even if they remain a political ally.

Will: The Warrior's Hearttag

Will (Wilfred or Willeen Steinmann) is your fiercely loyal Southern Commander. This romance is built on shared hardship, unwavering trust on the battlefield, and showing them there is more to life than duty and war. They respect strength, decisiveness, and a ruler who stands by their soldiers.

Key Quests & Decisions:

• "The Siege of Winter's Pass" (Chapter 3): You must give Will full command of the defense and back their tactical decisions, even when they seem risky. Praising their leadership to the War Council afterwards is essential.
• Hidden "Influence" Stat: Will's romance is governed by a hidden Influence score. You raise it by choosing dialogue options that encourage them to look beyond the battlefield. Key phrases include: "There is more to life than duty," and after a victory, "I hope you'll be there for the good times, as well."
• Lock-In Point: Will's romance is locked in during the quest "A Thief's Honor" in Chapter 7. After a tense infiltration mission, they will confess their feelings. You must reciprocate clearly. This is also where low Influence will cause them to hesitate and retreat, closing the path for good.

Killing Valerius's family if they are captured, or showing cowardice in battle, are the fastest ways to lose Will's respect and end the romance. They need a partner who is as strong and honorable as they are.

02

Can You Romance Your Enemies?tag

One of the most compelling and difficult paths in Arcadie II is the forbidden romance with your primary antagonist. This is a high-stakes route defined by betrayal, secret meetings, and the potential to alienate all of your allies.

Valerius: The Shadow Commandertag

Valerius, the Northern Commander and architect of the war against your family, is a secret and challenging romance option. This path is only possible if you made specific choices in Arcadie: Second-Born, namely sparing him after the final battle. Pursuing him requires a high Intrigue or Pacifism score and a willingness to make morally ambiguous decisions.

This is not a story of redemption, but one of mutual fascination and a dangerous alliance. Valerius is drawn to a ruler who demonstrates cunning, ambition, and a capacity for ruthlessness that mirrors his own. Or, conversely, a ruler whose unwavering commitment to peace intrigues him.

Requirements for the Path:

1. Valerius Must Be Alive: You must have chosen to spare him at the end of the first game.
2. Secret Correspondence: In Chapter 2, when you intercept a coded message, you must choose to decipher it yourself and respond secretly, opening a backchannel communication with him.
3. Betray Your Allies: During the "Siege of Winter's Pass," you will receive a secret objective from Valerius. You must sabotage a part of the fortress's defenses, an act of treason that gives him an advantage but prevents catastrophic losses on both sides. This will severely damage your relationship with Will.

The entire romance plays out in stolen moments and coded messages. You must consistently choose dialogue options that express a fascination with his perspective and a desire for a different kind of truce. Siding with him often means directly opposing Cyril and Will, and if your deception is discovered, they may abandon you entirely. The lock-in point is a clandestine meeting late in the game during the "Truce of the Blackwood" quest, where you must choose to formally ally with him against other threats, cementing your dark pact.

03

Key Mechanics for a Successful Romancetag

Beyond dialogue, your relationships are governed by a few core systems. Understanding them is key to ensuring you don't accidentally end a romance you're trying to pursue.

The Approval System Explainedtag

Every potential partner tracks an Approval score, which is a numerical representation of their feelings toward you. This is influenced by dialogue choices, but more significantly by major plot decisions. Most romances require this score to be above 60% to progress to their final stages. You can't see the number directly, but character reactions and summaries in the journal provide strong clues.

Major Approval shifts occur after key quests, like the examples listed for each character. A single decision here can grant or cost 15-20 points. In contrast, a single flirtatious or supportive line of dialogue might only grant 2-3 points. Prioritize the big choices. Actions that directly contradict a character's core values—like an act of tyranny in front of Cyril or cowardice in front of Will—can trigger massive Approval penalties.

Critical Choice Crossroadstag

Unlike many RPGs, gifting is not a mechanic in Arcadie II. Your relationships are forged entirely through your actions and words. Certain moments in the story serve as critical crossroads that can make or break a romance permanently.

Here are the most important ones to watch for:

Bold choices are the only way forward. Trying to please everyone by taking a middle path often results in failing to meet the emotional intensity required to lock in any romance.

04

Frequently Asked Questionstag

• Can you romance multiple characters at once? No. While you can be friendly and flirt with both Cyril and Will early on, you will eventually face a "love triangle" scene where they force you to choose one. You cannot maintain a romantic relationship with a main ally (Cyril or Will) while also pursuing the enemy romance with Valerius.

• Are there any same-sex romance options? Yes, all major romance options are available to both male and female player characters. The game is designed to be fully inclusive of gay, straight, and bisexual relationship paths.

• Does your romance choice affect the main story ending? Absolutely. Your chosen partner has a significant impact on the final chapters and the epilogue. Your relationship will influence political alliances, the fate of certain factions, and the ultimate direction of your kingdom. An alliance with Valerius, for example, leads to a drastically different world state than one with Cyril.

• Who is the hardest character to romance? Valerius is by far the most difficult. It requires you to have met specific conditions in the previous game and to make a series of treacherous, counter-intuitive choices that actively harm your relationships with your core allies. It is a path of high risk and high, albeit dark, reward.

05

Final Taketag

The romance system in Arcadie II: Cold Lands is not a simple side quest but a core pillar of the narrative. Your relationships are deeply intertwined with the political and military struggles of your kingdom. Whether you choose the path of stable, supportive love with an ally or the thrill of a dangerous liaison with an enemy, your decision will have far-reaching consequences that define your reign and your legacy.